Tell If A Leather Wallet Is Real or Fake: 5 Steps & 8 Tips

Have you ever been confused by faux leather wallets that look almost identical to genuine ones? These days, fake leather wallets are everywhere. They are often crafted with synthetic materials that closely mimic the appearance and feel of real leather. Some sellers even use misleading terms like "genuine leather" or "PU leather" to deceive customers. 

If you're planning to invest in a high-quality leather wallet, it's crucial to know how to spot a fake on your own. This simple guide will walk you through the key differences, helping you make an informed decision and avoid falling into traps.

What Are Fake Leather Wallets Made of?

Fake leather wallets are usually made from synthetic materials like polyurethane (PU) and polyvinyl chloride (PVC). These materials are coated onto fabric and then embossed with patterns to mimic the texture of real leather. Other common materials used include microfiber and bonded leather. While they look similar to genuine leather, they lack the same durability and quality.

Tips to Tell If A Leather Wallet Is Real or Fake

Check the Leather Wallet With Your Eyes

• Check the labels and tags on the wallet. If you see terms like "synthetic," "polyester," "leatherette," or "vegan leather," it's not real leather. Be cautious if the label says "manmade material" or doesn't mention the type of leather. These are signs that the wallet is likely fake. Labels that state "real leather," "top grain leather," or "full grain leather" are more reliable indicators that the wallet is genuine. Manufacturers usually display this information proudly when it is real leather.
• Check the surface for natural imperfections. Real leather is made from animal hide, and each piece is random and distinct. It may show minor scratches, wrinkles, or irregularities. These are good signs of authenticity. If a wallet looks too perfect or uniform, it might be fake. Trust your eyes and look closely at the details.
• Check the cut and edges of the leather wallet. Real leather often has uneven, natural edges, while fake leather usually has straight, uniform edges. Real leather may also have small imperfections or variations, while fake leather looks more smooth and consistent. If you notice a plastic-like feel or backing, it might be fake leather.

Feel the Leather Wallet

• To see if a leather wallet is real, start by touching it. Real leather warms up when you hold it. Fake leather stays cool. When you press your finger into the leather, real leather wrinkles and forms small creases, just like human skin. Fake leather stays stiff and only dents without wrinkling. You can also bend the wallet a bit. Real leather changes color and shows natural wrinkles. Fake leather is hard to bend and stays the same color.

Smell the Leather Wallet

• To tell if a leather wallet is real, smell it. Real leather has a natural, earthy scent. Fake leather smells like plastic or chemicals. If you're unsure, visit a store and compare the scents of real and synthetic leather items. The difference will be clear.

Try Flame and Water Tests on the Leather Wallet

• Light a flame and briefly hold it close to the leather. Real leather will not catch fire easily and might darken or smell like burnt hair. Fake leather will catch fire quickly and produce a strong, unpleasant odor that smells like plastic or chemicals.
• We do not recommend this method. If you choose to do so, test it on a hidden spot in the wallet.
• Real leather is porous. Place a few drops of water on the leather wallet. Real leather will absorb the water if it’s not waterproofed, darkening as it does. Fake leather, made from synthetic materials, will not absorb the water. It will stay on the surface or run off without changing the color.

Check the Price of the Leather Wallet

• Real leather wallets are usually more expensive due to their quality and craftsmanship. If a wallet is very cheap, it's likely fake leather. High-quality leather wallets reflect the cost of sourcing and processing real leather. If the price seems too good to be true, it probably is.

Don’t Be Fooled by the Color

Color alone won't tell you if leather is real. Bright or unusual colors can still be genuine. Both real and fake leather can be dyed. Pay attention to the texture, smell, and feel of the leather. Price can also be a clue, as real leather is usually more expensive. Don’t let color deceive you.

Is Real Leather the Same as Genuine Leather?

It's a common misconception that needs to be clarified: "real leather" and "genuine leather" are not the same. "Real leather," also known as 100% leather or true leather, typically refers to high-quality types like full-grain and top-grain leather. 

While "genuine leather" is technically real leather, it is considered a lower grade compared to what the industry typically regards as "real leather."

What Type of Leather Is Used for Wallets?

Full Grain Leather

Full grain leather is the highest-quality leather from the top layer of the hide. It’s tough, durable, and keeps its natural markings. It looks good over time as it develops a beautiful patina. Though it's pricey, wallets made from full grain leather last long and are unique.

Shop our best-selling full grain leather wallet.

Top Grain Leather

Top grain leather comes from the layer just below the full grain. It’s processed to remove imperfections, making it look more smooth and uniform. This type is easier to work with and offers a good balance between quality and affordability.

Further Reading: Full Grain vs. Top Grain Leather.

Genuine Leather

Genuine leather is a lower grade made from the lower layers of the hide. It’s softer and easier to handle but not as durable. It’s cheaper, making wallets made from genuine leather more affordable, though they may not last as long.

Bonded Leather

Bonded leather is made from leftover leather pieces glued together. It’s the cheapest and least durable leather. Wallets made from bonded leather are budget-friendly but tend to wear out quickly. Bonded leather is not considered real leather. Avoid it if you want to buy a real leather wallet.

Does Real Leather Peel?

No, real leather does not peel. If leather is peeling, it is likely faux or bonded leather.

Summary & Furthermore

We hope this guide helps you tell the difference between a true and fake leather wallet. Use your eyes, hands, and noses to check, feel, and smell. Telling true or fake isn’t as hard as you might think. 

If you are planning to buy leather wallets, especially ones of high quality, remember to use these tips to spot real leather and avoid being cheated. Or, you can visit Zitahli for trusted premium leather wallets made from full grain and top grain leather.